Dear Decaturish – DeKalb delegation should study form of government before tinkeringFILE PHOTOS: State Sen. Emanuel Jones speaks during a May 13 press conference about Gov. Brian Kemp vetoing Senate Bill 53.
We accept letters to the editor. Letters to the editor are opinions of the authors of the letter, not Decaturish.com. Everyone has an equal opportunity to submit a letter to the editor. So if you read something here and don’t like it, don’t jump on our case. Write a letter of your own. All letters must be signed and are typically between 500 to 800 words. We reserve the right to edit letters for length and content. We also reserve the right to publish longer letters if we need to. To send your letter to the editor, email it to [email protected]
A proposal has emerged from State Sen. Emanuel Jones, to alter the DeKalb form of government by eliminating the two DeKalb County super district commissioners and creating seven commission districts of equal size. This is a flawed and incomplete proposal that only should be considered in a much more comprehensive charter review process. It would also have a significant unintended consequence of eliminating an important zoning protection for DeKalb neighborhoods.
In DeKalb’s unique form of government, the County is divided into 5 county commission districts and 2 super-districts – one representing the eastern half of the county and another representing the western half of the county. This effectively provides each citizen with two representatives on the Board of Commissioners.
The theory and practice of the super district is that these two members bring the Board of Commissioners a broader perspective about the needs of DeKalb. By their larger size, the super districts are more diverse than the smaller 5 commission districts. The super district commissioners must build consensus and bridge differences across this diversity to stay in office. In the politically divided world of 2022, having elected leaders who must build consensus across diverse communities should be recognized as an asset to local government.
The unintended consequence of Senator Jones’ proposal is that DeKalb neighborhoods would lose a critical protection against unwanted zoning changes if the super districts are eliminated. Under current law, if the district commissioner and the super district commissioner are both against a zoning change in your neighborhood – the zoning change is automatically denied, regardless if the majority on the Board of Commissioners vote for the proposed development. This is an important ward courtesy. If the super district commissioner is eliminated, a zoning change could be approved in your neighborhood even if your district commissioner is opposed to the development. Commissioners outside your neighborhood and commission district will be making the zoning decisions if the super district is eliminated. County Commissioners would be less accountable to voters for changes in zoning.
The reason stated for eliminating the super districts is that DeKalb County population grew by 6% in the last census, and supposedly seven district commissioners would be closer to the people. By this logic, we should revert to the super districts if DeKalb loses population after the next census. The stated argument for eliminating the super districts just doesn’t make sense.
What does make sense is a thorough review of the charter and the entire form of government in DeKalb with its elected CEO. The current charter (formally known as the Organization Act) was proposed after an in-depth study in 1979. After an approved voter referendum, it became effective in 1984. Individual legislators should not tinker with DeKalb form of government. It requires a careful study that minimizes unintended consequences. The structure of the Board of Commissioners should not be selected and imposed by state officials. The citizens of DeKalb deserve to vote on the form of government that sets tax rates and manages essential services. If elected officials recognize the need to improve local government, the DeKalb Delegation, the CEO and the Board of Commissioners should try once again to advance a charter review commission. After all, since the last charter review, the population of DeKalb has grown by 58%.
What is the optimum number of commissioners? Should there be super districts? What’s the proper balance between the legislative and administrative functions? Local governments vary in size and organization across the country. Finding the best fit for DeKalb won’t be easy, but it can be accomplished with political leadership, citizen leadership and professional experts in local government. Let’s get this study done now before the next CEO takes office in 2025.
– Davis Fox
Davis Fox is a retired city planner who has been active in DeKalb politics and government for 30 years.
Want Decaturish delivered to your inbox every day? Sign up for our free newsletter by clicking here.